Malaysia: Trade unions condemn whipping of migrant worker
Various trade unions, human rights groups and civil society organisations closed ranks to condemn the whipping of migrant worker Sabri bin Umar at the Tawau Prison in Malaysia. The groups said that the whipping has been carried out despite a pending appeal.
The groups also called for the abolition of whipping as a corporal punishment, saying it is against international human rights standards.
Below is their joint statement.
We the 45 undersigned groups and organisations are shocked that Indonesian migrant worker Sabri bin Umar was whipped at the Tawau Prison on 23/6/2022 despite there being an appeal at the High Court regarding his conviction/sentence by the Session Court which have yet to be heard. The law in Malaysia clearly states that the sentence of whipping shall not be carried out until the appeal is heard and determined.
Convicted Cannot Be Whipped Until Appeal Heard And Decided
Section 311 of the Malaysian Criminal Procedure Code states, ‘Except in the case of a sentence of whipping (the execution of which shall be stayed pending appeal), no appeal shall operate as a stay of execution, but the Court below or a Judge may stay execution on any judgment, order, conviction or sentence pending appeal, on such terms as to security for the payment of any money or the performance or non-performance of any act or the suffering of any punishment ordered by or in the judgment, order, conviction or sentence as to the Court below or to the Judge may seem reasonable.
For any other sentence, other than whipping, the convicted is required to file an application for stay of execution pending appeal.
Sabri ‘Wrongly’ Convicted Then Wrongly Whipped On 23/6/2022 Before Appeal Heard
On 19/4/2022, the Session Court convicted Sabri for committing the offence pursuant to Section 6(1)( c) Immigration Act 1959/63, and sentenced him to 11 months imprisonment and 5 whippings. He was unrepresented at that time.
Section 6(1)( c) Immigration Act (1) states that. ‘No person other than a citizen shall enter Malaysia unless- (a)…(c) he is in possession of a valid Pass lawfully issued to him to enter Malaysia; or..’
As such, a documented migrant worker like Sabri bin Umar can never reasonably be found guilty of this Section 6(1)( c) Immigration Act offence, for he was a documented migrant worker and his entry and presence in Malaysia were in accordance to law.
A perusal of court documents revealed that the Immigration documents tendered to the court was FALSE, as it stated that there was no records of entry and exit for Sabri. It failed to disclose the truth, that Sabri was indeed a documented migrant worker for the past about 7 years, and that he was in the employ of one Fu Yee Corporation Sdn Bhd in Tawau, Sabah, Malaysia. His work permit also had been renewed by the Immigration Department in 2022, and should reasonably be valid for a year.
In fact, prosecution had also failed in their duty to properly investigate before charging Sabri. An investigation would have revealed that Sabri was documented worker who cannot be charged for a Section 6(1)( c) Immigration Act. It must be pointed out that Sabri was arrested at his workplace on 5/4/2022. There also seem to be no charges against the employer, Fu Yee Corporation, for harboring or employing an undocumented worker.
The appeal to the High Court was filed on or about 22/4/2022, and this appeal has not yet been heard and decided upon. Sabri was wrongly whipped on 23/6/2022.
Migrant Workers and employers that violate worker rights
For a migrant worker, even after his employment agreement comes to an end, the employer has the duty or responsibility to ensure safe return back to the migrant’s country of origin. Hence, even if the immigration work permit/pass that allows for legal presence ends, an employer has the duty to keep the migrant worker safe, including making needed application for pass/permits to allow legal presence in Malaysia until employer can arrange the return to home country.
Some ‘bad’ employers do sometimes wrongfully terminate, and quickly, even forcibly, send migrant workers back to countries of origin. This denies migrant workers access to avenues of justice to pursue claims of wrongful termination and reinstatement, claims for wages/monies still owing by employers to workers and other legal claims. Unfortunately, in Malaysia many of the avenues of justice including labour departments, industrial relation departments and even courts require physical attendance of the complainant/claimant, failing which it assumes that the migrant worker is no longer interested and the process to ensure justice ends.
Some other worse employers may just cause the cancelation of permits, and then may even cause or facilitate migrants to be arrested, charged and convicted for being undocumented, and then deported.
In the case of Sabri Bin Umar, who is also a union member of the Sabah Timber Industry Employees Union (STIEU), who claims that he was wrongfully terminated by his employer on 4/4/2022, and then was arrested by police on 5/4/2022 and was detained until charged and convicted on 19/4/2022. However, Sabri bin Umar did manage to file a wrongful dismissal claim in the Industrial Relations Department on 19/4/2022 seeking reinstatement, whereby this process is ongoing.
The employer, who knew that Sabri was not an undocumented worker failed to bring to the attention of the police, prosecutors and court this material fact, which reasonably would have meant Sabri would not be charged, let alone be convicted for being illegally in Malaysia under Section 6(1)( c) Immigration Act. Fu Yee Corporation should be doing the needed to end the current serious miscarriage of justice.
Whipping, a Corporal Punishment must be abolished
Sabri’s case has come to light, but there is concern about whether others have been whipped before their appeal is heard and disposed of. Whipping is a corporal punishment that inflicts serious physical and psychological injury, where victims are known to pass out even before the full sentence is carried out.
The Immigration Act 1959/63 was amended and as of August 2002, and the sentence of whipping was introduced for use against undocumented migrants. According to Prisons Department records, 47,914 foreigners were found to have violated the Immigration Act from 2002 to 2008. Of these, 34,923 were whipped.
The Malaysian Bar is unequivocally and unreservedly is against all forms of corporal punishment, including caning or whipping, in accordance with the United Nations Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (“UNCAT”), and international human rights norms. SUHAKAM (Malaysian National Human Rights Commission) has also long recommended that the Government of Malaysia prohibit the use of corporal punishment of caning and whipping.
- Call for Malaysia to immediately apologize and do the needful to ensure justice be done for the wrongful or illegal whipping of Sabri Bin Umar before his criminal appeal/s is heard and determined, and that actions be taken against those responsible;
- Call for the immediate abolition of whipping, a form of corporal punishment in Malaysia.
- Call on Malaysia to immediately ratify the UN Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment.
Apolinar Z Tolentino, Jr.
For and on behalf of the 45 organisations listed below
MADPET (Malaysians Against Death Penalty and Torture)
Building and Wood Workers International (BWI) Asia Pacific Region
WH4C (Workers Hub For Change)
Asosasyon ng mga Makabayang Manggagawang Pilipino Overseas (AMMPO) in Malaysia
Black Women for Wages for Housework
Citizens Against Enforced Disappearances, CAGED
Civil Society Action Committee
Domestic Caretaker Union (DCU), Taoyuan City. Taiwan
Federasi SERBUK, Indonesia
Federasi Serikat Buruh Kehutanan Perkayuan dan Pertanian Serikat Buruh Sejahtera Indonesia (HUKATAN)
Federation of Indonesia Workers’ Awakening (FKUI)
Haiti Action Committee
Hong Kong Federation of Asian Domestic Workers Unions, Hong Kong
International Domestic Workers Federation (IDWF)
International Women's Rights Action Watch Asia Pacific, Malaysia
Japan Innocence and Death Penalty Information Center (jiadep.org)
Koalisi Buruh Migran Berdaulat, Indonesia
Labour Law Reform Coalition(LRRC), Malaysia
Malay Forest Officers Union (MFOU), Malaysia
Malaysian Trade Union Congress Sarawak (MTUC – Sarawak), Malaysia
Migrant Care, Indonesia
Migrant Forum in Asia (MFA)
National Union of Transport Equipment & Allied Industries Workers, Malaysia
Network of Action For Migrants in Malaysia(NAMM)
North South Initiative(NSI)
Persatuan Pekerja Rumah Tangga Indonesia Migran (PERTIMIG), Malaysia.
Persatuan Sahabat Wanita Selangor (PSWS), Malaysia
Sabah Plantation Industry Employees Union (SPIEU)
Sabah Timber Industry Employees Union (STIEU)
Sarawak Bank Employees Union (SBEU), Malaysia
Sarawak Dayak Iban Association
Singapore Anti Death Penalty Campaign
Scalabrini International Migration Network (SIMN)
Sedane Labour Resources Centre, Indonesia
South Africa Domestic Service and Allied Workers Union (SADSAWU), South Africa
Teoh Beng Hock Trust for Democracy
The Cross-Regional Center for Refugees and Migrants, Lebanon
The William Gomes Podcast, United Kingdom
Timber Employees Union of Peninsular Malaysia (TEUPM)
TIEUS (Timber Industry Employee Union Sarawak)
United Domestic Workers of the Philippines , Philippines
Union of Forestry Employees Sarawak (UFES), Malaysia
Women of Color/ Global Women’s Strike